Tender Herb Mustard Lamb

Last Easter, I whipped up this mustard-coated lamb roast that blew everyone away. My mother-in-law even asked for my recipe – which feels like winning the cooking lottery! That herby-mustard layer forms this amazing outer shell that locks in moisture, turning even the biggest lamb doubters into fans asking for more.

My lamb-hating brother gobbled up three portions and then subtly hinted he'd love me to "cook this again maybe" during his upcoming visit next month.

Essential Ingredients

• Boneless leg of lamb: Go for lamb from Australia or New Zealand for a gentler taste that'll win over reluctant eaters.
• Dijon mustard: Forms the zingy foundation for your herb coating. Try whole grain if you want some extra bite.
• Fresh herbs: Get the real thing – fresh rosemary and thyme truly make this dish pop.
• Garlic: Go all in – the bold flavor matches up perfectly with lamb.
• Soy sauce: Just a splash adds richness without pushing it toward Asian flavors.
• White wine: Softens the meat and builds that wonderful pan liquid.
• Good quality olive oil: Helps everything stick and adds some luxury.

Pin it

My Cooking Process

Starting Steps

I always thoroughly dry the lamb with paper towels before putting on the mustard mix. This trick helps everything cling better and boosts the flavor punch. Getting the meat to room temp isn't optional – it's absolutely key for even cooking throughout.

Mustard Mixture

I spread the mustard blend generously across every inch of the lamb, working into all the little spaces. Your hands work best for this job – really work it in deeply. Don't worry about getting messy!

Cooking Method

I start with a hot oven to build that gorgeous crust, then drop the heat for perfect cooking inside. A meat thermometer is a must – lamb costs too much to ruin by guessing when it's done.

Wait Time

The toughest part comes after cooking! You'll want to slice right in, but those 15-20 minutes of rest make all the difference between juicy meat and dry disappointment. I just cover it loosely and finish up my side dishes during the wait.

I stumbled onto the lamb-mustard combo totally by chance when I ran out of mint jelly one day. I threw together some Dijon with herbs as a quick tableside spread, and it tasted so much better that I started cooking the lamb with it from the start!

What To Serve With It

This roast goes great with fluffy mashed potatoes or crunchy roasted ones that can soak up the sauce. For veggies, anything green fits perfectly – try roasted asparagus, green beans, or Brussels sprouts for nice color. Add a nice red wine like Cab Sauv or Syrah to round things out.

Personalize Your Dish

Try mixing in a spoon of honey for a touch of sweetness in the crust. Play with different herbs like mint and oregano for a Mediterranean feel. Want some kick? Add horseradish to the mustard coating. A bit of lemon zest can also wake up all the flavors nicely.

Keeping Leftovers

Extra lamb makes the best sandwiches next day. Slice it super thin, put it on good bread with some arugula and leftover mustard spread. When warming up leftovers, go low and slow – around 300°F with foil on top and a splash of broth to keep things juicy.

Pin it

Pro Tricks

• Get your butcher to butterfly the leg for more even cooking
• Mix up the mustard coating a day ahead for deeper flavor
• Get yourself a good instant-read thermometer for spot-on doneness

I once thought big cuts of meat like lamb were too fancy for me to cook. Then this recipe showed me that sometimes the easiest methods give the most impressive results. The mustard and herbs do the heavy flavor lifting, and your oven handles most of the work. It's now my go-to dish that looks like I slaved away all day when really I was chilling with some wine while it cooked!

Frequently Asked Questions

→ What temperature means lamb is medium-rare?

Check with a thermometer; when the inside hits 135°F, take it out and let it sit for 20-30 minutes.

→ Can I prep this dish early?

You can mix your mustard coating a day before, but coat and cook the lamb fresh for the best flavor.

→ What should I serve with this lamb?

This goes great with creamy mashed potatoes, roasted veggies, crunchy salad, or even grilled potatoes.

→ Can I swap fresh herbs with dried?

Fresh herbs are better for aroma, but 1 teaspoon each of dried rosemary and thyme works as a backup.

→ Why let the lamb rest before slicing?

Resting lets the meat juices spread evenly, making each bite taste better and juicier.