Pickled Pepper Onion

A zingy pepper and onion relish turns boring meals into taste adventures with its perfect mix of tangy zip and gentle sweetness. This handy topping adds bold color and lively flavor to your dishes, making everything from backyard burgers to fancy sandwiches taste amazing with little work but tons of impact.

I found this by accident when I needed to use up garden peppers before the cold hit. What began as just avoiding waste became my family's most wanted topping. These days my friends show up carrying empty containers, hoping to snag some of my newest batch to take home - that's when I realized it's something special.

Vibrant Ingredients List

• Bell peppers give a sweet crunch and bright colors—try mixing red, orange and yellow ones for a topping that looks as good as it tastes
• Onions add rich flavor that perfectly counters the sweetness—regular white ones work great but red onions create pretty purple streaks
• White vinegar delivers that classic pickle tang—its simple taste lets your veggies be the star
• Apple cider vinegar adds soft fruit notes that smooth out sharper flavors—plus it's got health perks that make me feel good
• Sugar cuts through the sour kick with needed sweetness—don't cut back here, it's what makes everything work together
• Mustard seeds create tiny bursts of texture and spice that excite your taste buds—these little flavor dots are essential
• Celery seeds bring an earthy flavor that's subtle but important—they're the hidden magic in this mix
• Turmeric adds warmth and that beautiful yellow color—with inflammation-fighting benefits too
• Salt boosts all the other flavors—I like kosher salt for its pure taste

Pin it

Easy Cooking Steps

Cutting Your Veggies

First, slice your peppers and onions super thin. I try to get onions you can almost see through and pepper strips skinnier than a pencil. Thin slices let the pickle mix soak in fast and make sure each bite tastes amazing. Put all these in a big bowl that can handle heat and set them aside while you make the pickle mix.

Making The Pickle Mix

In a good pot, mix your vinegars, sugar, and all those tasty spices—mustard seeds, celery seeds, turmeric, salt, black pepper, and red pepper flakes if you want some heat. Get this mix bubbling while stirring until you can't see any sugar granules. This hot mix doesn't just melt sugar but wakes up all the flavors hiding in those spices.

Pouring It Hot

When your pickle mix is bubbling and all the sugar's gone, carefully tip this hot liquid over your sliced veggies. The heat partly cooks the peppers and onions, making them just soft enough while keeping their nice snap. Stir everything well so all the veggie pieces get covered in that golden liquid.

Letting It Cool

Let your mix cool down on the counter, giving it a gentle stir now and then. While it cools, the veggies start changing, soaking up all those bright flavors from your spiced liquid. Don't rush—good things are happening even if you can't tell yet.

Waiting For Flavor Magic

Put your cooled relish in clean jars and stick them in the fridge for at least a day before trying. This waiting time really matters—the flavors smooth out and blend together during this rest. What might taste too vinegary at first turns into a perfectly balanced topping after sitting awhile.

My father-in-law, who swears he hates anything pickled, accidentally put this on his hot dog last summer and now sneaks it onto everything. When I caught him eating it straight from the jar with a fork, I knew I had a winner for life. Now I make twice as much, knowing half will disappear to his house in old jam jars that somehow never come back.

Tasty Pairing Ideas

This tangy relish turns a basic grilled cheese into something amazing—just spoon some inside before cooking. At BBQs, set it next to the usual toppings for hot dogs and burgers—you'll be shocked how many folks pick it over ketchup. I love putting a big scoop on top of a bagel smeared with cream cheese for a quick lunch that feels fancy without any real work.

Fun Twists to Try

Play around with different pepper mixes—maybe throw in a jalapeño or two for mild heat, or swap half the bell peppers for fennel bulb to get a surprise licorice flavor. For holiday meals, mix some cranberries and orange peel into the basic recipe for a festive side for turkey or ham. In summer, I sometimes add fresh corn cut right off the cob during the last five minutes for sweet little pops of texture.

Storage Advice

Keep your relish in clean glass containers with tight lids in the fridge, where it'll stay good for up to two weeks—though at my house it's usually gone way before then. The flavors keep developing while stored, so it's fine to make it several days before you need it. Don't use metal containers for storage, as the vinegar can mix with some metals and change the taste.

Pin it

Smart Cook's Tips

• Try a mandoline if you've got one for super even, thin slices that pickle perfectly
• When giving as gifts, process filled jars in boiling water for 10 minutes so they don't need refrigeration
• Don't toss the leftover liquid when the veggies are gone—it makes a fantastic starter for salad dressings

My grandma used to make something like this relish every summer, but her recipe was lost when she passed. I tried for years to match those flavors from memory, and this version finally captures that special taste from my childhood summers. When my mom tried it, she got quiet for a second, then looked at me with teary eyes and just said, "You found it." Now it's become my family tradition too, linking our generations through the simple magic of peppers, onions, and spices.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ How long will this stay fresh in the fridge?

It should stay good for about two weeks when kept in clean, sealed jars in the fridge.

→ Can I mix up the colors of peppers?

Of course! Using vibrant red, yellow, green, and orange peppers brightens up the flavor and presentation.

→ Is this safe for canning?

This version is for fridge storage only. For canning, you'd need to follow a proper food preservation guide.

→ What if I want it less sweet?

You can cut the sugar, but it balances the tartness. Start by halving the sugar and adjust as needed.

→ What dishes go well with this?

Pair it with hot dogs, burgers, sandwiches, cheese plates, grilled meats, or mix it into tuna or chicken salad.

→ How can I make it milder?

Skip the chili flakes for a more gentle flavor that everyone will enjoy.