Christmas Eve Cinnamon Vanilla Pie

This Christmas Eve cinnamon-vanilla custard pie is the holiday dessert that always brings my family to the table with anticipation and big smiles. Its creamy custard filling is kissed with gentle cinnamon and real vanilla, nestled in a crisp pie crust. If you want a dessert that feels festive but not fussy this pie delivers both comfort and elegance with every silky bite. I learned years ago that it is just the thing to quiet the excitement of Christmas Eve and fill the house with the scents of celebration.

The first time I made this pie was a Christmas Eve when snow was coming down in thick flakes outside. Now my siblings insist I make it every year and it has become our little tradition. There is always someone who steals a sample before dinner because it is just impossible to resist.

Ingredients

• Eggs: provide the custard with silky texture and stability. Always use fresh eggs at room temperature if possible for the smoothest filling.
• Whole milk and heavy cream: work together for richness and softness. Pick high-quality dairy with a fresh clean scent for best flavor.
• Sugar: gently sweetens without overpowering the spices. Choose fine white sugar for easy dissolving in the custard base.
• Ground cinnamon: gives the pie its warm festive soul. Look for a fragrant cinnamon that smells sweet and spicy. You can even try infusing the milk with a cinnamon stick if you like extra depth.
• Pure vanilla extract or real vanilla bean: rounds out the flavor with cozy sweetness. Avoid imitation vanilla for the best holiday aroma.
• A crisp pie crust: acts as a buttery foundation. A homemade all-butter crust is worth the effort but store-bought will save time especially if you blind bake for crispness.
• Optional nutmeg or a hint of orange zest: can add a little sparkle. Use a whole nutmeg and grate just a tiny bit fresh for brighter spiciness.

Step-by-Step Instructions

Prepare the Crust:

Start by chilling your dough if homemade or unwrapping a quality store-bought crust. Roll it out evenly to fit a 9-inch pie dish and gently press it into the base and up the sides. Lay in parchment paper and fill with weights or dried beans to blind bake at 375 degrees for 15 minutes. Remove the weights then bake for another 5 minutes until the bottom is just golden. Cooling the crust before filling helps maintain crispness.

Infuse the Dairy and Spices:

Heat milk and cream in a saucepan with cinnamon and vanilla. If you are using a cinnamon stick or vanilla bean let them steep over medium heat until steaming. Avoid letting the mixture boil.

Whisk the Eggs and Sugar:

In a large bowl whisk eggs and sugar until the color lightens and everything is completely smooth. Slowly ladle in a bit of the hot dairy while whisking constantly to gently warm the eggs and prevent curdling. Repeat with the rest of the milk mixture.

Strain and Pour the Custard:

To achieve a perfectly smooth filling strain the custard through a fine-mesh sieve into a clean bowl. Pour it carefully into the cooled crust right up to the rim.

Bake the Pie:

Turn down the oven to 325 degrees. Bake the pie for about 35 to 40 minutes. The edges should look set but the center should still give just a little wobble. If you like you can bake the pie in a water bath to avoid surface cracks and guarantee extra creamy texture.

Cool and Set:

Let the pie cool on a rack until it reaches room temperature then chill it in the refrigerator for at least two hours to ensure the custard is fully set. Patience is key for that perfect slice.

Save

My favorite part is scraping real vanilla beans into the warm cream which makes the custard smell like a dream and fleck each slice with pretty dots. Last year we cut the pie surrounded by candles and my little niece said it tasted like Christmas itself.

Storage Tips

For best results store the pie loosely covered in the refrigerator. If you need to make it further ahead bake and chill completely then wrap the whole pie tightly and freeze for up to a month. For thawing move to the fridge overnight. Serve slices chilled for a classic texture or gently warmed if you prefer a softer custard.

Ingredient Substitutions

If you need dairy-free options swap coconut milk and coconut cream for the dairy and use a plant-based crust. Almond milk also works but the custard will not be quite as rich. You can try maple sugar for a different sweetness or add a tiny splash of bourbon for extra warmth.

Serving Suggestions

Serve with a dusting of powdered sugar or extra cinnamon. Add a dollop of softly whipped cream or a scoop of ice cream for a festive touch. For holiday flair garnish with sugared cranberries or a sprig of rosemary and pair with coffee or mulled wine.

Save

Cultural and Family Roots

Custard pies like this one have a long history on holiday tables across Europe and America. The simplicity of eggs and milk transformed with spice is pure old-fashioned comfort. Our family started making this cinnamon-vanilla twist for Christmas Eve so it always signals the start of celebration for us. It is a timeless dessert that feels both special and deeply familiar.

Recipe FAQs

→ Can I use a graham cracker crust instead of pastry?

Absolutely, a graham cracker crust adds a sweet note and offers a convenient make-ahead option that pairs beautifully with custard.

→ How do I keep the custard from becoming watery?

Be sure to bake until the edges are set but the center still jiggles. Allow the pie to cool and chill fully to achieve the best texture.

→ Is this pie better served warm or cold?

This dessert is traditionally enjoyed chilled or at cool room temperature, which creates a silky, creamy mouthfeel. Warm slices may be gently reheated if desired.

→ Can I make a dairy-free version?

Yes, substitute coconut milk for the cream and use a dairy-free crust for a lactose-free alternative. The flavor will be slightly different but still deliciously festive.

→ How can I prevent cracks in the custard surface?

Bake the pie at a gentle, moderate temperature, remove when slightly jiggly in the center, and consider baking in a water bath for a flawless appearance.

→ Are there any variations for this dessert?

You can personalize this pie with spice blends like nutmeg or cardamom, add a splash of rum, or opt for gingerbread or cookie crusts for a different twist.