Easter Egg Cake

Every Easter for the last few years, I've whipped up this Egg Cheesecake for our family dinner, and now everyone starts asking about it weeks ahead! The combo of those soft-colored malted eggs against the blue frosting just feels like springtime and creates a gorgeous holiday treat with barely any work.

Last year my aunt, who normally handles all the desserts at family get-togethers, actually wanted my recipe. That's when I knew I had a true hit on my hands!

Ingredients List

• Graham cracker crumbs: Get them already crushed or smash whole crackers in your food processor.
• Robin's egg malt balls: These speckled shell candy-coated chocolate malted milk eggs really make the dessert pop.
• Cream cheese: Go for the solid blocks (not spreadable tubs) for the best filling texture.
• Sweetened condensed milk: Adds both sweetness and helps everything firm up without baking.
• Cool Whip: Creates that airy, light consistency. You can use properly stabilized homemade whipped cream too.
• Lemon juice: Just a tiny bit enhances the flavor without making it taste citrusy.
• Blue food coloring: Try to use gel coloring if possible – it gives that beautiful robin's egg shade without making the filling runny.

Pin it

Preparation Steps

Making the Base

When I make the graham cracker crust, I've learned that using a measuring cup's bottom to press it down creates the most level surface and tidy edges. Putting it in the fridge while working on the filling helps it stay firm.

Creating Layers

For those stunning layers, the secret is splitting the filling and only adding blue color to half. I put down the white layer first, then carefully add the blue layer on top. A small spatula really helps get everything smooth and even.

Creating Speckles

For that authentic speckled robin's egg look, I lightly dust some cocoa powder across the top before adding the eggs. A tiny fine-mesh strainer works great for getting a subtle, even dusting.

Decorating with Eggs

I start by putting whole eggs around the outside edge, then fill the middle with broken pieces. Using both whole and crushed eggs makes it look more interesting and makes serving much easier.

I first came across this recipe when I needed something that wouldn't take up my oven during Easter cooking madness. While the no-bake feature first caught my eye, it's the beautiful presentation that keeps me making it every year!

Ways to Serve

This cheesecake looks amazing as the main attraction on any Easter dessert table. Sometimes I add a few sprigs of fresh mint around the plate for a touch of green. For a more casual brunch, try making single servings in small jars – just stack the layers and top each with an egg or two.

Customization Options

You might want to swap in a chocolate cookie crust instead of graham crackers for extra chocolate flavor. Adding a dash of vanilla to the filling boosts the taste nicely. If you want something more sophisticated, mix in some lemon zest. You could even swirl in some raspberry jam into the white part for a fruity kick.

Keeping It Fresh

This treat stays good in your fridge for up to 3 days. I typically make mine the day before serving, which lets the flavors blend perfectly and the filling set completely. If you have extras, just cover them loosely with plastic wrap so the top doesn't get smashed.

Pin it

Smart Tricks

• Add the blue food coloring bit by bit until you see that perfect robin's egg blue shade
• Make sure your white layer is totally flat before putting on the blue layer to avoid mixing
• Before taking off the springform pan, slide a thin knife around the edge for easy removal

This Egg Cheesecake has become such a family tradition that I'm pretty sure they'd all be upset if I didn't bring it! There's something really rewarding about making a dessert that looks fancy but comes together so easily. And honestly, who doesn't love cutting into those pretty colored layers?

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I prep this cake a day early?

Absolutely! It's better if you do. Prepare it completely, cover lightly with plastic wrap, and refrigerate overnight for a firmer texture.

→ What can I use instead of Cool Whip?

Whip up 3 cups of heavy cream with 1/3 cup powdered sugar until stiff. Gently mix this into your cream cheese blend to replace Cool Whip.

→ Is it okay to freeze the cake?

Sure, but wait to add the candy until right before serving. Freezing with the decorations might cause the colors to bleed when thawed.

→ What if I can't find robin's egg candies?

You can swap in other pastel candies like mini chocolate eggs, jelly beans, or even light-colored M&Ms for a similar effect.

→ Why is there lemon juice in the mix?

Lemon juice gives a slight tang that balances the sweetness and mimics a classic cheesecake flavor—even without baking.