Save
I've gotta tell you about my favorite sweet treat that brings together two comfort food favorites in a totally magical way. I stumbled on this apple bread pudding pie one chilly fall night when I had some brioche sitting around and freshly picked apples. When those spices start floating through the house while it's in the oven, it takes me right back to my grandma's kitchen, but with this extra layer of creamy goodness.
Total Comfort
There's something really wonderful about mixing those apple pie flavors into a rich, custardy bread pudding. Every mouthful brings you that warm, cozy feeling whether you're eating it for dessert or treating yourself at breakfast. My family just can't get enough of it - they'll eat it any hour of the day.
Quality First
Great bread pudding always starts with great bread. I only use challah or brioche because their buttery, rich feel really makes the whole dish better. And you need apples that are crisp and fresh - I usually grab Granny Smiths or Honeycrisps since they give you that perfect mix of sweet with a bit of tang.
First Steps
You've gotta start by drying the bread, which I've found is super important for getting the texture just right. Sometimes I'll let the cubes sit out all night, but when I'm short on time, popping them in a low-temp oven works just as well. The best part comes next - putting those spiced apple pieces between bread layers to create these amazing little flavor spots throughout.
Just Right Consistency
It took me a while to nail the perfect texture. You want the custard part to be set but still have that creamy feel, kind of like really good French toast in the middle. I always keep my kitchen thermometer nearby - it tells me exactly when everything's done just right.
Save
Signature Spices
I really enjoy creating my own apple pie spice mix - it makes the whole house smell wonderful. That mix of nutmeg, cinnamon and allspice brings back so many memories of baking with my mom during fall. I'll throw in a tiny bit of cardamom too - that's my little kitchen secret.
Dishing Up
The toughest part is waiting just long enough before serving. I love watching vanilla ice cream slowly melt down over the warm pudding. Sometimes I pour caramel sauce all over it too because really, why not go all the way?
Fast Bread Solution
When I can't wait for bread to naturally get stale, the oven trick works wonders. Just a couple hours at low heat and those bread chunks are ready to soak up all that tasty custard mixture.
Prep Ahead Wonder
I really like that I can get this ready the night before a big breakfast or dinner with friends. I just put it all together, cover it up and stick it in the fridge. Next day it only needs its baking time and soon the house smells absolutely amazing.
Storing Extras
Leftovers don't hang around long at my place, but when we do have some, they stay good in the fridge. A quick heat-up in the oven brings back that just-baked taste. The microwave works in a pinch but the oven really brings back that wonderful texture.
Save
Upcoming Comfort
I'll sometimes make a second batch just for freezing. Single servings wrapped up well keep that fresh flavor for up to 3 months. It's like having a warm hug waiting in your freezer for when you really need one.
Change It Up
Though the original version tastes amazing, I love trying different twists. Sometimes I throw in pecans or dried cranberries. Those tart little cranberry bursts or the crunch from toasted nuts really add something special to the texture.
Top It Off
You can try so many different toppings. My homemade caramel sauce always goes over well but sometimes I whip up a vanilla bourbon sauce that's really something special. Even just some maple syrup drizzled on top works great.
Slimmer Version
When we want something not quite so heavy, I'll use skim milk and cut back on sugar. The apples already give it natural sweetness and trust me, it's still totally delicious. Nobody ever notices those missing calories.
Celebration Favorite
This has turned into my favorite dessert for holidays. It's perfect for busy celebrations since I can make it ahead of time. Plus that wonderful smell filling up the house just makes everything feel more festive.
Save
Perfecting Technique
The secret to amazing bread pudding is making sure each bread chunk gets enough custard. I gently push down on the layers to help everything soak in evenly. Those extra few minutes of care really make all the difference.
Apple Choices
The apples you pick really matter a lot. I like using different kinds together, some for sweetness and others for tartness. They need to stay firm while cooking too - nobody wants soggy apples in their bread pudding.
Flavor Boost
Playing around with spices is how I make this dish truly mine. A bit of ginger adds nice warmth while a tiny amount of cloves gives it depth. It's fun to experiment until you find what tastes best to you.
Heating Tips
For leftovers, I always use the oven instead of the microwave. That slow, gentle heat really brings back all the original tastes and textures. It's definitely worth waiting those extra minutes.
Great Companions
On cold nights I love serving this with hot apple cider or a warm cup of chai. Something about those spicy, warm drinks goes so well with the pudding. It's comfort food at its absolute best.
Save
Recipe FAQs
- → Why use older bread?
- Older bread soaks up the custard without becoming soggy. Leave it out overnight or dry it out in a cool oven for a few hours.
- → Can I mix my own apple spice?
- Absolutely! Blend 2 tablespoons cinnamon, 2 teaspoons nutmeg, and 1 teaspoon allspice. Keep it sealed tight for later use.
- → How long can I keep it?
- Keep it in the fridge for up to 4 days, covered. Reheat single servings in the microwave until warm and ready to eat.
- → Why save the juices from cooking apples?
- Pouring these flavorful juices over the baked pudding adds extra taste and moisture, making it even better.
- → Can I make parts in advance?
- Sure! You can stale the bread and prep the apples earlier. Put it all together and bake close to serving time for the freshest taste.