Pin it
I've gotta tell you about these Butterfinger Balls. I stumbled on this treat during my kitchen experiments and now my family begs for them constantly. There's something magical about mixing smooth peanut butter with crunchy graham bits and that distinctive Butterfinger texture, all wrapped up in smooth chocolate coating.
The First Snack To Vanish At Parties
These treats never stick around long at get-togethers - they're gone within seconds! The coolest thing? They're super easy to make without turning on your oven. I keep some frozen for when friends pop over unexpectedly or when I need a sweet fix. My whole neighborhood now asks me to bring these to community events.
Your Ingredient List
- Peanut Butter: 1 cup, pick smooth for silky results or chunky if you want extra texture.
- Butter: ½ cup, make sure it's soft and unsalted for easier blending.
- Vanilla Extract: 1 tsp, brings out all the other flavors.
- Powdered Sugar: 2 cups, run it through a sifter for a bump-free mixture.
- Graham Cracker Crumbs: 1 cup, smashed into tiny pieces for the perfect texture.
- Butterfinger Candy Bars: 4 bars, broken up for mixing and topping.
- Chocolate Bark: 12 oz, melted down for dunking your balls.
Creating Your Treats
- Start The Foundation
- Grab a big bowl and beat the peanut butter, butter, and vanilla until it's smooth. Slowly add the powdered sugar while scraping down the sides.
- Build The Crunch
- Mix in your graham cracker bits and smashed Butterfinger pieces until everything's well combined.
- Form Your Treats
- Get your cookie scoop and make 1 ½ tablespoon balls, rolling them between your hands. Put them on a tray lined with parchment and stick them in the freezer for 30 minutes.
- Give Them A Coat
- Melt your chocolate and dunk each ball using a fork or toothpick. While the chocolate's still wet, sprinkle crushed Butterfinger on top or add some fancy drizzles.
- Wait A Bit
- Let your chocolate-covered balls harden on the parchment paper at room temp or in your fridge before you dig in.
Pin it
Storage Smarts
These goodies stay tasty in the fridge for weeks when you keep them in sealed containers, though they never hang around that long at my place. I put wax paper between layers so they don't stick together. Want them to last even longer? Toss them in the freezer and grab one whenever you need a chocolate kick.
Mix It Up
I'm always trying new twists on these. Last month I swapped in Snickers and couldn't believe how good they turned out. My family also loves when I use white chocolate for coating. For kid parties, my little girl adds rainbow sprinkles to make them extra fun.
Party Favorites
These treats started as Christmas cookie tray items but now they show up at everything from baby showers to wedding receptions. I love that I can make them days before an event, which saves me tons of stress. Guests think they took forever to make – I just smile and nod.
Pin it
Insider Tricks
After making countless batches, I've learned a few things. If your mix gets too gooey, stick it in the fridge for 15 minutes before shaping. When you're melting chocolate, do short 30-second microwave bursts and stir between them. And take my word for it – a fork works way better than toothpicks for dipping.
Kitchen Buddies
My kids can't wait to help make these. They're pros at smashing candy bars and rolling the balls. Sure, the kitchen gets a bit crazy, but seeing how carefully they add the toppings makes my heart happy. Plus they're starting to enjoy cooking with me.
Make Them Fancy
When I want to impress, I'll put these in cute paper cups on my best serving dish. For presents, I found perfect little boxes at my local craft store. A quick zigzag of different colored chocolate on top makes them look totally store-bought.
Pin it
Treats For All
I've played around with different versions to fit everyone's needs. My next-door neighbor can't eat gluten, so I use gluten-free graham crackers in hers. My sister follows a vegan diet, so I make some with dairy-free chocolate. There's nothing better than watching everyone enjoy the same treats together.
Tasty Combos
These balls taste amazing with a warm cup of coffee when you're just chilling at home. When my book friends come over, I serve them with fresh strawberries and blueberries. They grab them by the handful – something about fruit and chocolate just works so well.
The Ultimate Gift
These have turned into my signature present during the holidays. I pack them in cute tins with the recipe written out by hand. My friends start asking me about them as soon as fall ends. Homemade goodies just carry something special during Christmas time.
No-Fail Party Snack
When I need something guaranteed to please a crowd, I grab these. They don't mess up during car rides and stay perfect for hours without refrigeration. I always bring extra recipe cards because someone will definitely ask how to make them.
Pin it
Never Get Caught Empty-Handed
I've learned my lesson about running out, so now I keep a backup stash in the freezer. They thaw super fast and have saved me so many times when friends drop by without warning. Nothing makes visitors feel more welcome than pulling out homemade sweets just for them.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Which peanut butter works best for these bites?
Stick with regular peanut butter like Jif or Skippy. Avoid natural kinds—they're too oily and can mess up the texture.
- → How do I store these bites?
Keep them in the fridge in an airtight container. They'll last up to seven days if stored properly.
- → What chocolate works best for dipping?
Chocolate bark gives the smoothest finish and skips the need for tempering. You can also mix bark with chips or just use tempered chocolate chips.
- → Can I prepare these in advance?
Absolutely! Make them ahead and refrigerate until needed. They're perfect for pre-planning party snacks or holiday treats.
- → What are some good topping ideas?
Sprinkle crushed Butterfingers, colorful sprinkles, or flaky sea salt. Add toppings before the chocolate sets.