Crispy Cinnamon Sugar Cookies

I've been whipping up these crunchy cinnamon sugar treats ever since my grandma passed down her secret when I was little. They're what I turn to when sugar cravings strike but my cupboards are nearly empty. These simple delights have come to my rescue during countless nighttime sweet attacks when I'm short on fancy baking stuff.

My husband chuckled the first time I dubbed these "cookies" and claimed they were merely dressed-up toast. That is, until he demolished half the tray in one go during a football game. Now he regularly asks when I'm gonna "make those cookie toasts again."

Ingredients Needed

• Standard white bread forms the foundation - actually works better with cheaper brands
• Butter (don't hold back) delivers that deep, caramelized taste
• Sugar creates the delightful crunch we want
• Cinnamon adds that cozy, aromatic kick

Pin it

My Cooking Method

Getting The Bread Ready

I start with regular white sandwich bread - slightly older bread actually works better since it doesn't get soggy from the butter. I snip off all the crusts (my kids always fight to munch on these leftovers) and then cut each slice into triangles. Somehow triangles feel more cookie-authentic to me, but you can do squares or get creative with cookie cutters too.

Butter Dunk

Then comes the crucial part - warming up a hefty amount of butter and slathering it on every side of each bread piece. Don't go light here! The butter's what changes boring bread into something wonderful as it cooks. I use a brush, but you can just dunk each piece straight into your melted butter if you're feeling lazy.

Sweet Dusting

After the butter treatment, I combine sugar and cinnamon in a little dish and thoroughly coat both sides of each buttery bread bit. Again, go heavy here - you need a thick, complete layer that'll turn golden in the oven. Sometimes I throw in a tiny bit of nutmeg with the sugar mix when I want to get fancy.

Gentle Baking

The transformation happens in a 325°F oven for roughly 20-25 minutes. This low, patient approach is super important - it lets the sugar turn golden properly without burning. Your house will smell like a cinnamon bakery about halfway in. I usually take a peek around 18 minutes since ovens can behave differently.

Rest For Crispiness

Right when they come out, I move them to a wire rack. They might feel a bit soft initially, but they get super crispy while cooling down. Watching them change from bread to crunchy cookie is pretty cool - and tasting them is even better.

When I first served these to my kids' pals after school, one boy asked if he could tell his mom I was a real baker. I couldn't bring myself to explain it was just fancy buttered toast, so I just gave him a wink and said it was our family's special recipe.

Tasty Variations

I'll sometimes add a sprinkle of raw sugar on top for extra crunch before they go in the oven. During Christmas time, I mix some pumpkin pie spice into my cinnamon sugar for a holiday feel. My kids go crazy when I drizzle a simple powdered sugar icing over the cooled treats for an extra sweet touch.

Keeping Them Fresh

They store amazingly well in sealed containers - much longer than normal cookies, actually. They stay crunchy for 3-4 days on the counter. I've found that tucking a slice of bread into the container stops them from getting too hard if you plan to keep them around longer than a couple days.

Pin it

Smart Cooking Shortcuts

• When your bread feels too fresh, pop it in the toaster briefly before starting
• For super thin, ultra crispy treats, gently flatten each piece with a rolling pin before adding butter
• A tiny bit of sea salt on top makes an incredible sweet and salty combo

Though these aren't "traditional" cookies by definition, they've earned their spot in my favorite recipes. They've been the highlight of many unexpected coffee visits, after-school snacks, and late-night hunger fixes. Often the easiest recipes turn into the ones everybody talks about and wants again. These crunchy cinnamon sugar cookies definitely fall into that category.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I swap white bread for another type?

Sure, you can! Try whole wheat or other bread, but textures and tastes can differ. Wheat adds a nutty twist but might not crisp as much. Avoid overly soft bread or ones with big holes—they might break apart.

→ What’s the reason behind removing crusts?

Taking off the crusts gives a smoother texture and a prettier look. The soft bread absorbs the butter and sugar better. You can leave the crusts if you'd like a more rustic vibe!

→ Any flavor ideas to mix things up?

Totally! Sprinkle in a little cardamom or nutmeg for a spiced kick. Mix lemon or orange zest in with sugar for a citrusy zing. Adding vanilla to the butter is yummy too.

→ Why didn’t mine turn out crispy?

A few things might’ve gone wrong: your bread might’ve been too fresh, they may have needed a tad longer in the oven, your oven might not be hot enough, or they didn’t cool on the rack completely—cooling helps them crisp!

→ Can I prep these ahead for an event?

Absolutely! They stay fresh for 3–4 days in an airtight container at room temp. If they soften, pop them in a 300°F oven for 5 minutes, let cool, and they’re crispy again.

→ Got any dipping sauce ideas for these?

These are great alone but even better with chocolate or caramel sauce! Or try cream cheese dip or yogurt. They’re amazing with coffee, tea, or hot cocoa too.