Pin it
I stumbled upon these scrumptious Mushroom Shallot and Herbed Goat Cheese Tarts at a pal's get-together and practically begged them to share how they made them. Now they've become the top-requested starter at my place. The way the goat cheese blends into the mushrooms while the pastry turns golden and flaky makes me hungry just thinking about it. You'll see – these are gonna be your go-to party showstopper.
Heavenly Bites You'll Crave
These tarts always wow everyone who tries them, and honestly, they're super easy to make. The crisp puff pastry holds a filling that tastes like something from an upscale bistro. I can't get enough of watching friends' expressions when they first taste these delicious savory treats.
What You'll Need
- Puff Pastry: I always have some in my freezer – just remember to let it thaw beforehand.
- Shallots: A couple of these sweet little beauties chopped up small.
- Garlic: Use the real stuff, not powder – it really matters.
- Mushrooms: About two cups diced up – I just pick whatever looks good at the store.
- Herbed Goat Cheese: The rich, tangy star of our show.
- Olive Oil: Just enough to cook everything properly.
- White Wine: A bit for the pan and some for you while cooking.
- Fresh Herbs: I use whatever's growing on my windowsill.
- Salt and Pepper: Simple seasonings that pull everything together.
- Egg Wash: For that beautiful golden color we all love.
Let's Get Cooking
- Prep Your Pastry
- I start by heating my oven to 400°F. While it warms up, I take my thawed pastry and cut it into squares. A little egg wash gives them that shine, and you can play around with the edges if you want.
- Make Your Filling
- My whole house smells amazing when the shallots and garlic start cooking in the pan. Once they're tender and smelling great, I add the mushrooms. I love hearing that sizzle when the wine goes in, then I watch it cook down as I mix in the herbs.
- Assembly Time
- The fun part comes next – dropping that tasty filling onto each pastry square. I'm careful to leave space around the edges since they'll puff up as they bake.
- Oven Time
- They go into the oven for about 25 minutes until your kitchen smells incredible. When they're puffy and golden, they're ready to steal the spotlight.
- Grab One Quick
- I always eat one right away – they're just too good when they're warm from the oven.
Pin it
Insider Tips
After making these tons of times, I've picked up some tricks. Make sure your pastry is fully thawed or you'll struggle to work with it. Splurge on fresh herbs if you can – they really do taste better. And don't skip the egg wash – it's what gives these tarts that beautiful golden look that makes everyone want more.
What Makes Them Special
These tasty treats have been my dinner party savior so many times. That mix of flaky crust with creamy filling gets everyone talking. I love that I can make them ahead but still impress my guests like I've been slaving away all day.
Mix It Up
- Go Gentler: My sis uses cream cheese when making these for her little ones.
- Add Greens: I sometimes throw in some baby spinach or caramelized onions I've grown.
- Herb Options: I just use whatever fresh herbs look best that day.
- No Wine Needed: On busy nights I just use broth instead and it works great.
- Try It Sweet: A tiny bit of honey before they bake creates something magical.
Great Companions
I like serving these while they're still warm next to a fresh green salad. When I have company over, I put them on my favorite platter with some grapes and cool wine. It's just right for those long evenings chatting with friends around my kitchen island.
Pin it
Storing Extras
These tasty bites actually store pretty well. I stick any extras in containers and they're good in the fridge for a couple days. Just warm them up quickly in the oven to get that crispiness back. Sometimes I make extra to freeze before baking – they're perfect when unexpected visitors show up or when I want something fancy but don't have much time.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Which mushrooms should I use?
- Go for button, cremini, or mix in wild types for a deeper flavor. All work great!
- → Can I prep this early?
- Yes! Make the mushroom mix 1–2 days beforehand. Assemble and bake fresh for best results.
- → What’s a no-wine option?
- Swap wine with veggie or chicken stock. Add a squeeze of lemon for a zingy taste.
- → Why put holes in dough?
- It keeps the middle flat so the filling fits snugly. The edges will still puff just right.
- → Can I freeze these?
- Place unbaked ones in the freezer for up to a month. Cook them from frozen with a few extra minutes.