Pin it
Mouthwatering Party-Ready Italian Submarine Sliders
I'm always excited to pass along my favorite crowd-pleasers, and these Italian Sub Sliders are totally worth shouting about. Every mouthful delivers delicious Italian cold cuts, melty provolone, and tangy pickled peppers. When you bring these to your next get-together, don't be surprised when everyone wants to know how you made them.
What Makes These Sliders My Go-To Party Food
Being a frequent entertainer, I've learned to appreciate dishes that wow without the hassle. These sliders have come to my rescue many times during game days and festive gatherings. Their versatility is what I appreciate most. Got extra mouths to feed? Just pick up more rolls and increase the fillings. They're so quick to put together, you'll still have time to chat with everyone at your party.
My Can't-Miss Ingredient Roundup
- Hawaiian rolls: I always grab Kings Hawaiian because their touch of sweetness works magic against the meaty fillings.
- Deli ham: Spending a bit more on Applegate Black Forest Ham pays off with deeper flavor notes.
- Salami: The Columbus Italian Dry Salami brings that genuine Italian deli charm.
- Sliced pepperoni: I find Applegate pepperoni adds just the right smoky touch.
- Provolone cheese: Ask for fresh-sliced at the deli for the dreamiest melt.
- Hot cherry peppers: The Mezzetta brand delivers that ideal spicy zing.
- Peperoncini: Adding Mezzetta peperoncini gives each bite a fresh tang.
- Butter: I've found Kerrygold salted butter simply makes the whole thing shine.
- Italian seasoning: Don't hold back when adding this for authentic Italian taste.
- Fresh garlic: Freshly crushed garlic creates an amazing smell you can't fake.
My Step-by-Step Approach
- Stack your fillings:
- Cut those rolls straight across the middle. Load up pepperoni, salami, ham, provolone and those tasty peppers, then place the tops back where they belong.
- Create the flavor drizzle:
- Get your butter nice and liquid, then stir in crushed garlic and Italian seasonings. Paint this tasty mix all across the tops of your rolls.
- Bake to perfection:
- Wrap them up in foil and stick them in a 350°F oven for half an hour. Once they're golden and the cheese has melted, slice them apart and watch them quickly vanish.
Common Questions From Guests
- Too spicy for you? Don't worry, the peppers aren't overwhelming. If you want them milder, try sweet banana peppers or roasted red peppers instead.
- Need to serve lots of people? Easy fix. This recipe works great doubled or even tripled. Just buy more packages of rolls.
- Can't get Kings Hawaiian rolls? That's okay. Any type of connected dinner rolls will do the trick.
My Favorite Serving Suggestion
Want to know how I like to present these tasty treats? Serve them fresh from the oven when they're still warm and gooey. Put out some marinara sauce on the side for dipping and you'll take the Italian flavors to a whole new level.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can these sandwiches be prepped ahead?
- Definitely! Assemble them earlier in the day, keep them chilled, and bake with butter topping when you're ready to serve.
- → What’s the best way to store leftovers?
- Keep them in an airtight box in the fridge for up to two days. Heat them at 350°F for around 10 minutes to enjoy that crispy bread again.
- → Can I switch the meats in this recipe?
- Sure thing! Swap out the meats for turkey, roast beef, or even mortadella—whatever suits your taste.
- → Why cover the sandwiches with foil while baking?
- The foil stops the tops from getting too dark and keeps the sandwiches moist as the cheese melts.
- → Do I really need marinara sauce on the side?
- It’s not a must, but it’s a bonus for dipping! The sliders are packed with flavor even without it.