Southern Pimento Cheese

Mixing sharp cheddar with smoky gouda takes this southern favorite to a whole new level. Every velvety, well-seasoned mouthful combines the deep richness of cheese with bright pimento pops, making a spread that works just as well at fancy parties as it does in everyday sandwiches. I came up with this after we had dinner at a local BBQ spot where a simple starter got me hooked on finding that exact flavor mix at home.

Key Ingredients

• Freshly grated sharp cheddar delivers that classic zingy base.
• Smoked gouda provides that mystery element everyone asks about.
• Cream cheese gives it that perfect spreadable consistency.
• Sweet pimentos add bright bursts of pepper flavor throughout.
• Good mayonnaise brings everything together with extra richness.
• Thoughtfully selected seasonings boost flavors without taking over.

Save

Crafting Amazing Taste

Cheese Setup:

Bring all cheeses to room temp, then shred them yourself for the best flavor mixing.

Base Making:

Whip the softened cream cheese until light, slowly adding mayo until it's completely smooth.

Seasoning Mix:

Mix in your spices carefully so they spread evenly throughout the mixture.

Texture Building:

Mix in your freshly shredded cheeses, keeping some texture while making a cohesive spread.

Final Touch:

Carefully fold in the pimentos, letting their sweet flavor cut through the rich cheese.

Making It Silky Smooth

I'm always amazed watching separate ingredients turn into one velvety spread, especially seeing chunks of cheese slowly vanish into the creamy mixture while my mixer does the hard work, though I sometimes mix by hand because I like feeling the texture change with my spatula. The secret to getting it super smooth is taking your time - if you rush or use cold ingredients, you'll still get something tasty but you'll miss out on that silky feeling we want.

Flavor Balancing Magic

After making countless batches and getting feedback from my toughest critics (my neighbors who somehow always drop by when I'm in the kitchen), I've found that adding spices bit by bit and tasting as you go creates amazing layers that make people pause and smile with their first bite. Sometimes I'll throw in extra cayenne for a grown-up crowd, or use less heat and more mustard powder when kids will be eating it.

Family Favorite Status

Whenever I bring this spread to family dinners or block parties, someone always corners me asking how I made it, often telling me they never liked pimento cheese before trying this version. The aroma of it melting between sourdough slices brings my teens running faster than calling them for dinner, and watching my father-in-law trying to sneak thirds without being noticed has become something we all quietly laugh about.

Crowd-Pleasing Appetizer

Showing up at any gathering with this spread feels like I've got a secret weapon, especially when I put it in my grandma's fancy dish with some herbs sprinkled on top to make it look as good as it tastes. I love seeing people's reactions when they realize it's homemade pimento cheese instead of store-bought, and it's funny watching them try not to camp out by the food table. On regular weeknights, we love it thickly spread on toast with fresh tomato slices, or plopped onto hot baked potatoes right as they're opened.

Flexible Variations

Over years of making this, I've learned it takes to changes really well, like adding crumbled bacon for extra smokiness, mixing in finely chopped jalapeños for heat lovers, or trying different cheese combos when I feel like experimenting. Sometimes I make it super smooth for sandwiches, other times I keep it a bit chunky for crackers, and somehow each version becomes someone's favorite.

Storing Your Creation

I keep this in my special glass container with the red top that everyone knows not to use for anything else, and it stays good for about four days, though we usually finish it way before then. The taste actually gets better after sitting in the fridge for a day or two, like many good things that need a little patience, and letting it warm up before serving makes a huge difference in how it feels and tastes. I often make double batches just so we have enough for sandwiches after everyone goes home.

Save

Smart Cook Advice

Listen to your taste buds instead of just following measurements, since every cheese has its own character.

Don't skimp on letting ingredients reach room temperature, it's totally worth waiting.

Feel free to tweak the seasonings until it matches what you love.

When I think about how this recipe began - just trying to copy a restaurant appetizer I couldn't forget - and see how it's grown into something that's truly ours, I really appreciate how food becomes woven into our family stories. The ingredients might be basic, but the memories we've built around this spread, from quick family meals to big celebrations, turn it into something special. Each time I make it, whether I follow my usual way or try something new, I remember all the talks, laughs, and connections it's helped create around so many tables - and isn't that what cooking is really all about?

Recipe FAQs

→ How long will it last?

Store in the fridge in a sealed container, and enjoy within seven days.

→ Can I use bagged shredded cheese?

Freshly shredded cheese comes out creamier and gives a better texture than pre-shredded.

→ What pairs well with it?

Spread it on crackers, sandwiches, burgers, baked potatoes, or use it as a dip for celery sticks.

→ Can I tone down the spice?

Just leave out the cayenne if you'd like a milder, kid-friendly option.

→ Can I freeze this cheese spread?

It’s better fresh! Freezing affects the texture, so skip the freezer for best results.